5.0 from 123 reviews
Leave a Review

You've bought this product 0 times.

You've bought from this vendor 0 times.

Indian Creek Creamery

Whole Milk - Non-Homogenized

Dairy Products: Milk

Our cream line whole milk comes in a half gallon (64 fluid ounces). The milk is minimally processed and as fresh as it gets. The milk is non-homogenized, high temperature/short time pasteurized, and the milk goes from the cow to the bottle the same day! Because it is non-homogenized, the cream rises to the top, so if you don't want to skim the cream off the top for your coffee or other purposes, please be sure to SHAKE WELL to distribute the cream through the milk to enjoy the rich, creamy taste of milk as nature intended! USA / Ohio / Logan County


You must login or register to ask questions in the product forum.
Q: I am looking for heavy cream to make Mascarpone. Do you sell this? I have had some success with heavy whipping cream but I am trying to make it richer.

A: 'No, we do not sell heavy cream because we do not take any cream out of our milk.'

January 1st, 2022 person_outline Tim A.
Q: How much protein is in a serving

A: 'Our milk is tested at approximately 3.2% protein. We do not add anything or take anything out of our milk. Thanks for asking!'

November 28th, 2021 person_outline Rob W.
Q: When can you or Market Wagon provide the option to pickup the order at a nearby store (zip code 45242)? Spending $7 every week as delivery charges hurts but love your milk hence it would be good to have a pickup option.

A: 'Please take a look at our Facebook page or website for a list of stores that carry our milk if that is a better option for you - thank you for loving our milk!'

November 18th, 2021 person_outline Adnan K.
Q: We miss you! Please come back to NE Ohio! 🥰🥰

A: 'We are still looking for options to get our milk back to NEO....please check our Facebook page or website periodically to see a list of stores that carry our milk. Thank you for loving our milk!'

November 13th, 2021 person_outline Alexe K.
Q: How long is the expiration date on these? I received 5 half gallon milk bottles on Aug 24th and expiration is Sept 6th. So 2 weeks. Is that right ? I do not remember my milk having an expiration date of less than 3 weeks.

A: 'We put a best-by date of 3 weeks after the day we bottle the milk on each jug of milk. We find that the milk usually lasts about a week longer than that if somebody ends up having one in the refrigerator longer than 3 weeks. Some of your milk may have been carried over from the week before.'

November 11th, 2021 person_outline Smitha S.
Q: Just wanted to add a note that we’re anxious to see you back in NEOH! My hubs LOVES your milk so very much. Crossing our fingers you get the logistics worked out very soon, and praying fir your continued success no matter what. Just please don’t make us have to move back to Columbus to enjoy your products. {{{hugs}}}

A: 'Thank you so much for your kind words! We are still looking for options to get our milk back to NEO. Please check our Facebook page or website periodically for a list of stores that carry our milk.'

November 10th, 2021 person_outline Peggy H.
Q: I'm very sad to see that your products, the whole milk in particular, is not longer available in Northeast Ohio. It was your products that brought me to Market Wagon. I hope to see you back soon!

A: 'We hope to get our milk back to the NEO market just as soon as we can find a solution to our logistic issues. Thank you so much for your business and your patience with us!'

September 9th, 2021 person_outline Kurt M.
Q: Do you have a time frame yet when you will be delivering back to NE Ohio?

A: 'We are a small family farm and feel terrible that we haven't been able to get to NEO the last few weeks, but we are working hard to find a solution to our logistics in order to get our milk back up there. We appreciate all of our customers and your patience with us!'

August 6th, 2021 person_outline Sherri M.
Q: Help your milk is the only kind i can drink. Why did you stop delivering to the Northeast area

A: 'We are a small family farm and we are having trouble logistically getting to the NEO hub. We are working hard to find a solution to get our milk back to you - we appreciate your patience!'

August 5th, 2021 person_outline christine t.
Q: I've been ordering your milk regularly from NE Ohio. Why is it no longer available here? It this demand outgrowing supply? I've prayed for God to give you more cows.

A: 'You are so sweet! We are a small family dairy and are having logistic issues in getting to the NEO hub. We are working hard to find a way to get our milk back to your market...thank you so much for your business and your patience with us as we grow.'

July 22nd, 2021 person_outline Erik C.
Q: When will your milk be available in Northeast OH again?

A: 'We are unsure at this point exactly when our milk will be available in that market again. Sorry for any inconvenience.'

July 10th, 2021 person_outline Caitlin M.
Q: Is this sold in any store locally?

A: 'I am not sure where you are located, but if you go to our Indian Creek Creamery Facebook page, we have a list of stores that carry our milk. Thank you for your interest!'

June 11th, 2021 person_outline Miranda J.
Q: I fully understand the need to charge a delivery fee, but I'm finding it difficult in my position to purchase a half gallon with that fee. Is there any chance of you selling to Aldis or any grocery store in Columbus, Ohio area by chance?

A: 'Good afternoon! The delivery fee charged by Market Wagon covers anything you order on their website and I think it is very reasonable, but if you are only purchasing milk and would like to find it in a local store we have several listed on our Indian Creek Creamery Facebook page. Thank you so much for your interest in our milk!'

May 25th, 2021 person_outline Mohammad A.
Q: How do I cancel all auto orders?

A: 'I hope you got an answer from Market Wagon, but if not please contact them directly - they take care of all ordering.'

May 11th, 2021 person_outline Brian D.
Q: Is this milk processes using what is called UHT pasteurized?

A: 'No, our milk is not UHT (stands for ultra-high temperature) pasteurized. '

May 4th, 2021 person_outline Kelley K.
Q: When are you starting to packaging in 1 gal bottles?

A: 'We do not have any plans to package in 1-gallon bottles in the near future. Thank you for your question. '

April 18th, 2021 person_outline Sudhir J.
Q: Do you pick up and recycle used milk containers?

A: 'We do not pick them up but we encourage our customers to recycle them locally.'

March 24th, 2021 person_outline Laila E.
Q: Is it glass or plastic bottles

A: 'We use BPA free plastic bottles.'

March 18th, 2021 person_outline Martin Z.
Q: Will you ever have a gallon option?

A: 'We will not be offering gallons in the near future.'

March 8th, 2021 person_outline Sarah H.
Q: Hi this is the first time I bought the A2 non homogenized milk. I didn’t try yet but want to know whether it is a organic milk or not? Can I get a gallon of this milk?

A: 'Our milk is not certified organic, but our cows always have the choice to go to the pasture, they eat non-GMO feed, and they all have names - they are like a part of our famiy:) At this point, we are only bottling in the 1/2 gallon jugs.'

March 6th, 2021 person_outline Lidwin X.
Q: Do you sell 1 or 2% milk?

A: 'No, we do not. We do not add anything or take anything away from our milk by extracting the cream/fat from it. Research shows that the naturally occurring fat in milk is actually not unhealthy for us.'

March 2nd, 2021 person_outline Dawn M.
Q: Love your milk! How long does it stay fresh after opening?

A: 'If kept cold, we feel confident the milk should stay fresh for about a week. Thank you for trying our milk!'

March 2nd, 2021 person_outline Lauren T.
Q: What's the nutritional information?

A: 'We do not add anything or take anything out of our milk, and therefore we are not required to have it analyzed by a lab. Fluctuations in the cow's diet, time of year, etc. will affect the exact nutritional ratios. Typically, there are approximately 8-11 carbs and 120-160 calories per one cup of milk. '

February 28th, 2021 person_outline Frank B.
Q: Thank you for your delicious milk!!!! Do you know if we can feed it to cats? I know they recommend "raw" milk for cats. But, I don't think yours is considered raw, right?

A: 'No, our milk is not considered raw, but it should still be fine to feed to cats.'

February 14th, 2021 person_outline Brandi T.
Q: How many carbs?

A: 'Our milk is all-natural ....nothing added, nothing is taken away - therefore, fluctuations in the cow's diet, time of year, etc, will affect the exact nutritional ratios. An estimate is roughly 8-11 grams of carbs per one cup of milk. I hope this helps!'

February 8th, 2021 person_outline Diane S.
Q: What is the calorie count on your whole milk?

A: 'Our milk is all-natural ....nothing added, nothing is taken away - therefore, fluctuations in the cow's diet, time of year, etc, will affect the exact nutritional ratios. There are usually roughly 120-160 calories in one cup of raw milk. '

February 2nd, 2021 person_outline Patrice .
Q: Is there sodium in the milk? Can I get quart size?

A: 'We only sell our milk in the half-gallon size at this time. The sodium in milk is naturally-occurring and is present in small amounts. Our milk is all-natural......we do not add anything or take anything out of it. Milk normally has approximately 100mg of sodium in one cup.'

January 28th, 2021 person_outline Martha M.
Q: What are the calories of both milks?

A: 'Our milk is all-natural ....nothing added, nothing is taken away - therefore, fluctuations in the cow's diet, time of year, etc, will affect the exact nutritional ratios. There are usually roughly 120-160 calories in one cup of raw milk. '

January 8th, 2021 person_outline Patrice .
Q: Will you consider half/half, heavy cream and buttermilk?

A: Additional products are definitely being considered, but we are not sure when we will have them available. Thank you for your interest and support of our business-we appreciate our customers!

December 28th, 2020 person_outline GRACE G.
Q: If I order today for 44314 ... When would I receive my order? And do you deliver on the same day every week?

A: All orders in your area are delivered by Market Wagon every Thursday.

December 23rd, 2020 person_outline Cynthia L.
Q: The milk tastes better than any store bought. I remember out milk having cream at the top. This milk doesn't seem to have any. I am making yogurt from the milk as we speak

A: Thank you for reaching out to us. We do not homogenize our milk or remove any cream from it, so there is definitely cream in your milk. The bottle of milk should sit without being disturbed for 24 hours to give the cream time to rise to the top. Thank you for giving our milk a try! We hope our customers can "taste" the love and care that goes into our milk:)

December 22nd, 2020 person_outline Ronda G.
Q: thank you for doing this. This milk is delicious. I love it. I am orderng also for my grandbabies. I know that it will be so good for them. Can you tell me how early after our daughter breast feeds can her newest drink of this product? thanks again Judy Columbus, Ohio

A: Thank you so much for your kind words! I gave my children our cow's milk after I weaned them (around one year old), but that should be a question to ask her pediatrician:)

December 17th, 2020 person_outline Judy B.
Q: This milk is incredible. It tastes like when I was a kid. Thanks for choosing Market Wagon to deliver and also for having it available at Liberty Farm. I will check it out there this weekend too. I missed 'whole'some milk!! So glad to have found you guys!

A: Thank you so much! When we hear how much customers love our milk, it makes all the hard work worth the effort:) We appreciate you taking the time to write to us!

December 10th, 2020 person_outline Min L.
Q: It would be awesome to have a large mouth option so I can get the cream out easier for my coffee. If that's ever an option. Otherwise, I love your milk. Thank you!

A: Thank you for your compliment:) I completely understand that it would be easier to skim the cream with a larger mouth on the bottle, but this is the only style mouth that our bottles come in. Some people pour the milk into a pitcher so that it is easier to remove the cream. Or you can use a turkey baster. I'm sorry I can't be of more help - Thank you for your business!

December 8th, 2020 person_outline Levi W.
Q: Has anyone made clotted cream with this milk

A: Yes:) Just skim the cream from the top and it is perfect for clotted cream!

November 23rd, 2020 person_outline Teri P.
Q: How long is your milk typically fresh for? If I get some now, will it be good for...2 weeks? Or longer?

A: Our milk has a three week shelf life. We recommend laying it on its side so the cream is easier shake in if it will be sitting for a while before opening.

November 22nd, 2020 person_outline Xochi N.
Q: I don't think I sent anything before so allow me to take this opportunity to thank you for producing this wonderful milk! I used to buy the whole unhomogenized milk from another supplier in Ohio who is located in Wooster, and they sell their milk in glass bottles. as much as I like the idea of the glass bottles unfortunately between the constantly rising price of their milk coupled with a bottle deposit pretty much put it out of my reach. I was so thrilled to find your milk here on Market Wagon and it tastes actually better than your competitor's milk 😁. I do hope you consider in the future adding things like the butter you mentioned, half and half or heavy cream, and perhaps chocolate milk. You have a definite solid customer here.

A: 'Thank you so much for your kind words! We are so glad that you enjoy the fresh, raw-milk taste that our milk offers....our flash pasteurizer quickly heats the milk for only 18 seconds then cools it immediately so that the true flavor of the milk is not altered. We love it when customers get to taste the milk like nature intended!'

November 19th, 2020 person_outline Susan W.
Q: I fully understand the need to charge a delivery fee, but I'm finding it difficult in my position to purchase a half gallon with that fee. Is there any chance of you selling to Aldis or Trader Joe's in the future, or any shop in NKY, by chance?

A: Thank you for your question...the delivery fee is from Market Wagon, not Indian Creek Creamery. That is what they charge to deliver anything you order on their website. We just drop off our milk and they deliver it. If you would like to buy our milk at a store, it is available at Country Fresh Market and Wyoming Meat Market in the Wyoming area, or Liberty Farm Market and Halal Market in West Chester.

November 16th, 2020 person_outline Kaela L.
Q: Are the cows grass fed? And do you use hormones or antibiotics on the cows?

A: Our cows are always able to graze on pasture, but we do supplement their diet homegrown, non-GMO corn, and necessary minerals and proteins. We do not use hormones and limit antibiotic use to only when absolutely necessary for the health and well-being of our cows. Milk from treated cows is always discarded.

October 29th, 2020 person_outline Sonia K.
Q: I read this is partially pasturized but I'm not familiar with the terms. Is this pasturized to the point that any potential bacteria has been killed and it's safe for consumption? I don't want to take any chances with whole raw milk. Thanks. :)

A: Our milk is completely pasteurized. We have an HTST processor, which heats the milk to 170 degrees for 18 seconds then immediately cools it. The milk is non-homogenized, which allows the cream to rise to the top. Our rich, creamy milk tastes like raw milk because of the type of pasteurizer we use in combination with leaving all the cream in it. Thank you for your interest in our milk....I hope you will give it a try!

October 27th, 2020 person_outline Lauren T.
Q: My last order to MW I ordered 4 half gallons of whole milk. I did so because my road was going to be closed. All four jugs have an expiration date August 25th,I just opened my third jug and it has mold on the inside of the cap. The first two were fine and my fourth is fine also. Please advise. Alma

A: Oh no! I don't know why that happened, but we will make sure you get credited on Market Wagon for your inconvenience. Please send me the name that you use on Market Wagon so I can get you a gift certificate from us. You can message us privately on the MW website so that it isn't on our page for all to see. So sorry this happened!

October 16th, 2020 person_outline Alma G.
Q: what about GMO's?

A: We plant and feed non-GMO crops.

October 13th, 2020 person_outline lora .
Q: We are less than 3 miles outside your delivery area. I understand that there has to be a cutoff, so my question is, Do you deliver to any stores where I could find your milk?

A: We only deliver our milk to Market Wagon and they are the ones who set the delivery areas and deliver the products on their website. If you will tell me where you live I will tell you the closest store that carries our milk. Hopefully there is somewhere convenient!

October 12th, 2020 person_outline Kathi K.
Q: Do you have any delivery?

A: Do you mean other than Market Wagon?

October 11th, 2020 person_outline Nayeli S.
Q: Can I buy just heavy cream? I need about a quart, to make clotted cream.

A: We are not selling cream separately as of now. That is something we are looking into for the future:) Thank you for asking!

October 5th, 2020 person_outline Denise B.
Q: Last week one of my milks did not have the cream on top. Please make sure my order this time has the cream

A: All of our milk has cream in it. I would guess that since the milk was very fresh it did not have time to rise to the top. Make sure you let it sit undisturbed for at least 24 hours for the cream to rise.

September 25th, 2020 person_outline Janet O.
Q: Good morning. I have a coffee shop in Cincinnati. From August through May we can go through as much as 50 gallons of milk per week. Would you do any volume discount pricing?

A: Hello! For more information, please call Ray at 937-597-9429 or email us at Thank you for your interest!

September 19th, 2020 person_outline Chris H.
Q: Do you do in the paulding defiance or VanWert counties

A: Good morning! I am not sure if you are asking if Market Wagon delivers to those counties or if you can get our milk in those counties? At this time, Market Wagon does not deliver in that area. The closest towns to buy our milk would be Celina or Wapakoneta at the IGA stores. I realize that is not very close to you. Thank you for asking!

September 13th, 2020 person_outline Cheryl H.
Q: I received the order today. Last time I remember having milk like this was 62 years ago wan I left Italy. the cheese is delicious. No Question

A: Thank you so much for taking the time to leave your message! It touches our hearts to hear things like that and makes it worth the effort to be able to get fresh, non-homogenized milk to you and others:)

September 4th, 2020 person_outline Pietro T.
Q: do you sell goat milk as well?

A: No....we only milk our herd of cows and bottle their milk.

September 3rd, 2020 person_outline Judith R.
Q: Do you deliver unpasteurized milk?

A: No we don’t sell unpasteurized milk. It is actually not legal to sell unpasteurized milk in Ohio. Our milk does taste just like raw milk because we use a flash pasteurizer.

September 1st, 2020 person_outline Luciana .
Q: Is there any chance that you will switch to glass bottles in the future? I just wondered as I'd love to experience the full experience of having milk delivered in glass bottles :) so excited to try your product and appreciate the money going to the farmer directly.

A: Thank you so much for realizing what it means for us to be able to sell directly to the consumer:) we don’t foresee switching to glass bottles due to the intense labor needed to wash them. My husband and I do most of the farm work and bottling ourselves and there just isn’t enough time in the day. We appreciate your business!

August 27th, 2020 person_outline Melanie W.
Q: How long after you order will the milk be delivered?

A: Market Wagon delivers on Tuesdays and Thursdays - I believe you can choose which day when you place your order. Thank you for your interest!

August 20th, 2020 person_outline Mary D.
Q: 4692 PISGAH hill rd ripley oh 45167. You deliver or can I come there an where is it your located from me.

A: Good morning:) we deliver our milk to Market Wagon and they distribute it. They have home delivery or various pick up locations. They would be better equipped to answer your question than me- there is probably a link on their website to ask them directly. I’m sorry I couldn’t be of more help.

August 7th, 2020 person_outline Francis .
Q: I'm thinking about how to recycle your plastic bottles. One thought that has occurred to me is to melt it into flat sheets and then use a vacuum former to mold it into various shapes, for crafting. Can you please tell me what the melting point of the plastic is? Thank you!

A: You are so creative! I honestly have no idea what the melting point is. We purchase the jugs already formed, so I don't know anything about how to melt or form plastic. I am impressed with your resourcefulness, though and I hope you are able to do something fun with it!

August 6th, 2020 person_outline Marcia C.
Q: Will you deliver to my address 45176 zip?

A: Hello! I hope you got an answer to your question..... we deliver our milk to Market Wagon and they distribute all products, so that would be a question for them if they haven’t already answered. Thank you for your business!

August 2nd, 2020 person_outline Janet B.
Q: Is the milk organic?

A: Good morning! No, we are not certified organic, but we do pasture our cows and feed home- grown non-GMO feed as much as we can. We love our cows and give them all names and treat them like our children:) Thank you for your question!

July 29th, 2020 person_outline Cheyenne S.
Q: Do you make and sell buttermilk? I grew up on an Angus cattle ranch in the West. Our cattle, Alfalfa fed , produced meat that spoiled me for life. We had a Guernsey and a Jersey milk cows, and your whole milk is as wonderful as the milk I remember from my childhood . Thank you for raising such happy, contented cows.

A: Thank you so much for your nice comment! At this time we are only bottling our whole milk and A2 milk. Maybe we will add other products in the future. Thank you again for taking time to comment- we appreciate your business!

July 28th, 2020 person_outline FLOY A.
Q: I absolutely love your milk. I am having difficulty with separating the cream and have tried a turkey Bastet but that didn’t work. I would love to try making my own butter. For now, I am just shaking the bottle and drinking the cream with the milk. Any suggestions would be helpful.

A: First, make sure you are letting the milk sit undisturbed for 24 hours before you try to skim the cream. I actually put my milk in a Rubbermaid pitcher and skim the cream with a small ladle or measuring cup. I hope that helps! Thank you for your support of our creamery:)

July 25th, 2020 person_outline Kathleen M.
Q: I really like this milk and left a review few days back. But ever since this week’s delivery whenever am skimming off the cream I smell a strong odor of dry milk as if the milk was made using dry milk. By any chance are you adding any dry milk to it? I buy 6-8 bottles every week but never experienced this before,please clarify!

A: Good morning! We have not changed anything in our milk. We milk our cows first thing in the morning, then the milk goes through the pasteurizer and is immediately bottled. I have always lived on a dairy farm and had access to fresh milk daily, so I have never used dry milk and I don’t even know what it smells like. Sometimes changes in the cows’ diet will affect the taste/smell of the milk, and they have been eating grass in the pasture so that could explain what you are smelling. Thank you for asking- we appreciate your business!

July 21st, 2020 person_outline Maheedhar P.
Q: What is the shelf life of this milk?

A: Our "best by" date is 3 weeks from the day we bottle our milk. We do put a label on every jug that has the best by date on it. Thanks for asking!

July 16th, 2020 person_outline Anu .
Q: This is not a question but more of a compliment. The first sip of this milk and I was in heaven.Took me back to my childhood days and reminded me of how REAL milk tasted like.Makes tasty & delicious yogurt and cream on top is really thick which is really helpful in making homemade butter.You have found yourself a loyal customer,trust me on this😉 THANK YOU SO MUCH for all the services you are doing in these challenging & difficult times.

A: Thank you so much for your kind words! It is very heartwarming to hear about the pleasure our customers get from our milk.... we are grateful for the opportunity to bring it to you through Market Wagon.

June 22nd, 2020 person_outline Maheedhar P.
Q: This is not a question - rather a different method I follow to separate cream and make butter. We are from India and most Indians prefer cream to be the British style of clotted cream. I boil the milk, cool it, and refrigerate (it is important to not disturb the milk). The next morning there is a thick layer of clotted cream on top. I separate it and collect it in a glass jar. Usually I collect two weeks worth of cream. I bring this cream to room temperature and toss this cream into a regular smoothie blender (I have a little mini Ninja). After a few minutes the butter will rise to the top. Strain it, wash it, and use it however you like. Often, I turn the butter into ghee. I do this often and have no problems extracting cream and/or butter.

A: Thank you so much for sharing! I hope others see this and give it a try.... I will try it too:)

June 13th, 2020 person_outline Madhudaya S.
Q: what is the butterfat content

A: We do not take anything out of our milk- our cows average 4% butterfat, so that’s what our milk will be. The cream rises to the top of our milk, so you can always skim that off to use for butter/cream, etc. Thank you for your question!

June 7th, 2020 person_outline clement w.
Q: My zip code is 43162 outside of West Jefferson Ohio. Do you deliver there.

A: I believe that Market Wagon delivers to any county that borders Franklin county. That is a question for Market Wagon though.... we take our milk to them and they distribute everything- thank you!

June 5th, 2020 person_outline Berna Deene S.
Q: Is it still available to pick up order at This Guy’s Coffee?

A: You have sent this message to Indian Creek Creamery directly. Market Wagon does all the distributing and drop offs, so you will need to send that question to them.... I don’t think they can see your question here.

June 5th, 2020 person_outline Penny C.
Q: I am not able to buy milk. Is it sold out?

A: We have plenty is milk and will not run out... I will double check the website. If you are in Indiana, market wagon does not carry our milk there anymore. Thank you so much for checking!

May 31st, 2020 person_outline Alina M.
Q: Will the milk i receive this week been milked the same week or is it older refrigerated milk?

A: The milk you receive will have been freshly bottled this week.

May 30th, 2020 person_outline Smitha .
Q: What is the ordering cut off time? Time is 2141. I tried to order milk. and it will not let me.

A: We do not set the order cut off times....Market Wagon is responsible for all the technology....we just make the milk and deliver to Market Wagon:)

May 29th, 2020 person_outline John V.
Q: Can I pay at delivery time?

A: All payments go through Market Wagon.... there should be contact information on the website so that you can ask them that question- sorry I couldn’t be of more help!

May 28th, 2020 person_outline Sharifa k.
Q: Can I pick up?

A: I’m not sure if you meant to ask Market Wagon this question? We drop our milk off at Market Wagon and they take care of distribution.

May 23rd, 2020 person_outline Olivia .
Q: Do we need to boil this milk? I have purchased only once and am using without boiling. Please suggest if I need to boil it?

A: Our milk is safely pasteurized already- no need to boil:) It is not homogenized, while allows the cream to rise to the top. So don’t forget to shake well. Enjoy!

May 22nd, 2020 person_outline Hina M.
Q: How long is whole milk good for is the date on top of bottle.

A: Our milk has a best by date on the top of the bottle. We have found that it lasts a little longer than that, but I would try to use it by that date.

May 21st, 2020 person_outline Pat g.
Q: I'd love to buy a couple of pints of heavy cream from you every 2 weeks with my order. We'd also buy quarts of plain Greek yogurt, and unsalted butter. I've made yogurt from your milk and it's very good but I don't always have the energy to make it. This has been asked before so I'm hoping for an update. Thanks.

A: Good morning! Thanks for your patience with us:) We looked into separating our cream ( it sounded like a simple thing), but the regulations and equipment needed to meet the standards is not something our young business can afford at this time. Our next endeavor is butter making. Hopefully we can offer butter within the next 6 months. We will keep you posted:)

May 17th, 2020 person_outline Ruth F.
Q: Are your cows hormone free and vaccine free?

A: Our cows are not given rBST, but we do give vaccines to our cows to keep them and their calves healthy. The vaccines given to our cows do not transfer to their milk.

May 15th, 2020 person_outline Chantelle B.
Q: I emailed you (Market Wagon) what is your closest delivery to Sunbury, Ohio

A: Hello.... your question came directly to us( Indian Creek Creamery) instead of Market Wagon. I’m sorry but I do not know their pick up locations. There should be a way to contact them directly on their website. Thank you!

May 7th, 2020 person_outline Lee M.
Q: Could you tell me about pick up locations.

A: Pick up locations should be listed on Market Wagon’s website... your question had come directly to Indian Creek Creamery- we deliver our milk to the Market Wagon hub and they set the pick up locations and deliver products there.

May 7th, 2020 person_outline Zella s.
Q: How do you make your own butter from the milk? Have been wanting to do this but can’t from store bought, and I’m planning on buying your milk and other products from here on out! Thank you!

A: I’m sure you could find many recipes on the internet, but it is not hard at all. Take the cream off the top of the milk (some people use a turkey baster) and let in come to room temperature. Next you can use a mixer or even just shake a jar with a lid to churn the cream until the butter forms. Separate the butter from the buttermilk and make sure you press all of it out of the butter. You can add salt if you would like which makes the butter keep much longer than unsalted. Good luck!

May 6th, 2020 person_outline Mary B.
Q: We would love to buy this milk but it says unavailable in our local market although the delivery map shows we are right at the edge We are 6 mi NE of Sunbury, Ohio and 6 mi SW of Centerburg but have a Centerburg address and zip. Any way to meet somewhere in the area? I found no contact info for Market Wagon.

A: I have been told that they deliver to any county that borders Franklin county. There should be contact information on their website.

May 2nd, 2020 person_outline Lee M.
Q: How well does your milk freeze? Or do you recommend freezing?

A: I have not personally frozen our milk, but know others who do and it seems to work for them. I will try it and see how it does! Thanks for asking:)

April 30th, 2020 person_outline Stephanie S.
Q: what will be the delivery cost?

A: Good morning! I believe Market Wagon charges $5 no matter how much you order from their website to deliver. I know they also offer several pick up locations and I don’t think there is a charge for that. If I were you , I would ask Market Wagon directly to see which option works best for you. Thank you for your interest!

April 29th, 2020 person_outline Reiko S.
Q: Hi, Is this milk low pasteurized or high or ultra pasteurized.

A: We use an HTST( high temperature/short time) pasteurizer, which has a series of plates the milk goes through heating it to 168 degrees for approximately 17 seconds then cools it immediately as it runs through the plates. This minimal processing results in milk that tastes just like raw milk! I hope you will give our milk a try:) Thank you for your question!

April 23rd, 2020 person_outline Jameel A.
Q: Where is pick-up

A: I’m sorry but I don’t know the answer to that question. The pick up locations are determined by Market Wagon, and I believe they have them listed on the Market Wagon website.

April 21st, 2020 person_outline Cheryl L.
Q: I sure hope you will continue with Market Wagon as I have a milk allergy but your NON-HOMOGINIZED settles with me just fine and now they don't have it this week. Thank god I bought 2 last week!! Please come back soon!!!

A: Thank you for your comment! I love hearing from customers who are able to drink our milk:) I am assuming that you are from Indiana. We are actually in western Ohio, and from what I understand Market Wagon has found a milk supplier closer to Indianapolis, which helps them logistically. Thank you again for your kind words- we appreciated the opportunity to serve the customers in Indiana!

April 18th, 2020 person_outline Tim O.
Q: Hello, Is this milk ultra pasteurized? Thanks.

A: No, our milk is not ultra pasteurized. Thanks for your question!

April 16th, 2020 person_outline Judith A.
Q: Not a comment, but a compliment! I can't really justify using your service as we don't use much milk, but it makes us happy that you have resurrected the milk delivery sercice! Between 70 and 90 years ago, my grandfathwr , Adam Pope owned Pope Divco, the distributorship of Divco for Ohio, Indiana and Kentucky. Divco built all the milk and most other delivery trucks in that era. Your truck logo looks like a Divco. My Mom, now 89, still tells stories about her Dad and those trucks. We have a Divco truck front grill hanging on our barn! We are just proud to see that someone is 'carrying the goat's even now!!

A: Thank you for your message! We had never heard of Divco, but love hearing about how things were done in the past. We are happy to be able to offer our minimally processed milk directly to the consumer so that they can have milk that tastes the way it does straight from the cow:) Thanks again for sharing a bit of history with us!

April 16th, 2020 person_outline Lawrence B.
Q: Would you ever consider having an option for the milk to be bottled in glass instead of plastic? I understand that may cost more, but some customers may be willing to pay extra to cover those costs.

A: I do understand your desire for glass bottles, but for the time being it is just not feasible for us to switch to glass. My husband and I milk our cows and bottle the milk ourselves and we do not have the time or ability to wash the bottles, too. We know another family creamery using glass bottles and they spend 30 hours a week just washing bottles! Maybe if we keep growing we will someday have enough help to switch over:)

April 16th, 2020 person_outline Jennifer J.
Q: How many days on average is this milk good for in the refrigerator?

A: We have a 3 week “best by” date from the day it is bottled - we have found that it is usually still fine for another week after that - thanks for asking!

April 14th, 2020 person_outline Virginia F.
Q: Do you sell heavy cream or butter?

A: We do not sell cream or butter at this time. We are hoping to add butter in the near future. Thanks for asking!

April 13th, 2020 person_outline Joy H.
Q: Do you sell goat milk?

A: No, we only milk dairy cows on our farm.

April 13th, 2020 person_outline Jay .
Q: Do you have a herd share program to get raw milk?

A: Sorry we do not offer a herd share program.

April 10th, 2020 person_outline Ella W.
Q: Do you use anitbiotic for the cows or organic feed. Basically are any pesticeds involved anywhere?

A: We do very sparingly use antibiotics for our cows if they are sick or get mastitis. Milk from treated cows is ALWAYS discarded. We only grow non GMO feed and we do not use pesticides.

April 6th, 2020 person_outline betsy k.
Q: I use an instant pot to make yogurt, do you know if I would need to take the cream off first? Or would I just need to shake it up prior to making the yogurt? Thank you!

A: Good morning! You should just shake the cream into the milk prior to pouring it into your instant pot. It is so much better than store bought yogurt! Enjoy:)

March 9th, 2020 person_outline Jaime A.
Q: Are the cows 100% grass fed?

A: A majority of our cow's diet is made up of forages with only a small percent of their diet being grain to meet their energy demands. Our cows even have their own nutritionist who balances their daily ration to make sure all of their requirements are met!

March 8th, 2020 person_outline Danion T.
Q: Are your cows raised on pasture?

A: Yes, our cows are raised on pasture and that is where they prefer to spend their time, but they do have a barn to go in and out of in inclement weather.

March 3rd, 2020 person_outline Kim D.
Q: Do you have 1 percent?

A: We do not sell 1% milk - only whole milk at this time.

February 28th, 2020 person_outline Gina H.
Q: What is the difference between grocery store milk and this? Does it have Vitamins? Thank you!

A: Great question, unlike milk in the grocery store our milk is minimally processed, it is not homogenized (cream still rises to the top), no cream is taken out, and nothing is added to the milk. Our milk is packed with all the naturally occurring vitamins (and minerals) that makes milk such a healthy drink (B vitamins, A, D, E, K, etc.) - our milk has no added vitamins though, whereas many big milk companies add extra vitamin D.

February 21st, 2020 person_outline Brenda R.
Q: How is it delivered?

A: Our milk is transported to the Market Wagon location by our refrigerated truck and then deposited into the delivery bags for customer pick up. Sorry it took me so long to answer your question!

February 18th, 2020 person_outline VALERIE J.
Q: Do you make flavored milks? Chocolate in particular?

A: We aren’t making chocolate milk yet, but plan on offering it in the future. We appreciate your business and your inquiry:)

February 3rd, 2020 person_outline Tracey T.
Q: Do you all sell butter?

A: We are not making butter yet, but do hope to start making it soon...thank you for your interest!

February 1st, 2020 person_outline Marcy M.
Q: It's more of a comment-This milk taste really good, and made good yogurt but do not use it for making butter. I make butter all the time and I churned this for over 30 mins and it never got thick. I just made it into yogurt.

A: Thank you for your comment - I'm glad you are enjoying our milk! I'm not sure why you had trouble trying to make butter with it. I have never had a problem getting the cream to thicken. I would suggest using a turkey baster to remove the cream and letting it come to room temperature before churning. I hope that helps!

January 28th, 2020 person_outline STEVE H.
Q: Do you want the bottle back, or should I just recycle it?

A: Thank you for your question! These bottles are not meant to be re-used....please just recycle them. We appreciate your business:)

January 2nd, 2020 person_outline Dale Ann W.
Q: What is the shelf life for your milk?

A: Follow the "best by" sticker on each jug. As with most perishable products it should last a few days after the date on the sticker.

December 13th, 2019 person_outline Ashley McMann
Q: Hi, the milk is wonderful for drinking, does the pasteurization inhibit yogurt or cheesemaking? Love to drink it! Glad it is a Logan County product!

A: We are glad to hear that you like it! Our milk works wonderful for making cheese and yogurt, we have a couple customers that are using it for just that. Thanks for the question and feedback!

November 22nd, 2019 person_outline Gina Kay Landis
Q: Does this milk still have the cream or fat with it, I want the stuff that seperates with the cream on top that you have to shake up, like we had back in the old days.

A: Yes that is exactly what our milk is! A visible cream layer will rise to the top and needs to be shaken in.

November 22nd, 2019 person_outline David Jones
Q: Is this safe for kids under two to drink?

A: Yes it's totally safe! It has been pasteurized to kill any possible bacteria it has not been homogenized or had anything added or taken away from it, just milk as it should be. We've had great feedback from parents of young children who can't get enough of our fresh milk!

October 8th, 2019 person_outline AnnaBeth Feltner
star star star star star

format_quoteI cannot believe how delicious this milk is, even the kids noticed a difference.format_quote

January 1st, 2022 person_outline Brandy Y.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis is on a whole new level. Don’t want store bought after having this. format_quote

November 28th, 2021 person_outline Steve W. View Reply
star star star star star

format_quoteI like milk. I really like milk….and this is by far the most delicious milk I have ever tasted!!!format_quote

November 18th, 2021 person_outline ibo s. View Reply
star star star star star

format_quoteTaste that I have missed since I was a kid! Love this milk.format_quote

November 13th, 2021 person_outline Carol H. View Reply
star star star star star


November 11th, 2021 person_outline Tammy K.
star star star star star

format_quoteSeriously the best milk! Highly recommend!format_quote

November 10th, 2021 person_outline Brittany T. View Reply
star star star star star

format_quoteLove it! Back in my childhood flavor!format_quote

September 9th, 2021 person_outline Irina C.
star star star star star_outline

format_quoteI loved this milk. I'm only sorry I didn't realize I had to use it within a week.format_quote

August 6th, 2021 person_outline Bonita T.
star star star star star

format_quoteLovely milk. Makes my coffee taste even better. format_quote

August 5th, 2021 person_outline Beverly S.
star star star star star

format_quoteI have been in love with this milk since day one and told family and friends about it. But I used it to make some instant pudding and it blended in so much better, was almost instantly thicken and when I went to eat it the creaminess is beyond delicious. Love it! format_quote

July 22nd, 2021 person_outline Deborah J.
star star star star star

format_quoteHello I would love to buy the milk from a vendor near by. Please let me know any vendors in Springfield or Dayton. I know there is a map but not sure if they all sell this milkformat_quote

July 10th, 2021 person_outline PRATIK G.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis is the best milk we’ve had since we were children, and were old so that’s saying a lot! The grandkids love it too and can’t understand why it’s so much better than what comes from the grocery store. Customers for life here!format_quote

June 11th, 2021 person_outline Peggy H.
star star star star star

format_quoteMy new favorite milk. The amount of cream that gathers on top is the indication of quality. Doesn’t upset my stomach. Love it! format_quote

May 25th, 2021 person_outline Tetyana H.
star star star star star

format_quoteCould not love the milk more. Despite the Q&A saying the milk is good for a week, I drink it for 3-4 weeks and it's still good. Dunno how. I high recommend this milk, and can only hope they have room for more cows. format_quote

May 11th, 2021 person_outline Erik C.
star star star star star

format_quoteWe just got our milk. We ordered both whole and A2. To say it is amazing is an understatement. WOW. We forgot how good local, no hormone milk is. Customer for lifeformat_quote

May 4th, 2021 person_outline Steve R.
star star star star star

format_quoteMy husband was concerned that our kids would not enjoy the milk because it is so fresh....which is sad we think this way nowadays. However, they started consuming it faster and last week I should have started purchasing 2 instead of 1. I had to purchase an organic milk from the store to fill the milk need until our next delivery. Let me tell you, there is a HUGE difference. You do not notice it much going from supermarket milk to fresh milk, but you do notice it when you have to go from fresh to supermarket. Even the kids picked up on it. Needless to say, we are now spoiled and will purchase this milk as long as it is available. Also, there is something rather sentimental about having fresh milk delivered to your doorstep. This product is worth every penny! ESPECIALLY, if your kids are heavy into sports. My daughters are competitive swimmers and I am always looking for natural proteins and fats that they will actually consume willingly. This has helped A LOT! Thanks for offering this via market wagon and thank you for making this available in KY. This is THE product that keeps me coming back each week to order more items from other vendors. format_quote

April 18th, 2021 person_outline Carolyn W.
star star star star star

format_quoteYou can't find this farm fresh flavor in stores! Local and amazing! The whole family loves it. Will be keeping this in my weekly order!format_quote

March 24th, 2021 person_outline Heather W.
star star star star star

format_quotewe love this milk !format_quote

March 18th, 2021 person_outline Elizabeth F.
star star star star star

format_quoteThe cream not only rises to the top of the bottle, this milk rises to the top over all others. You will not buy store bought again!format_quote

March 8th, 2021 person_outline Tyler P.
star star star star star

format_quoteSo Happy I gave this milk a try. We Love it!format_quote

March 6th, 2021 person_outline Charity S.
star star star star star

format_quoteLOVE this milk!! I grew up drinking raw, whole milk from a dairy down the street and this is the closest I have been able to find.format_quote

March 2nd, 2021 person_outline Michelle G.
star star star star star

format_quoteLove having local milk delivered to my door! This is delicious over cereal, alongside homemade cookies, and it makes the best yogurt ever!format_quote

March 2nd, 2021 person_outline Michele S.
star star star star star

format_quoteExcellent! Makes the best ricotta cheese and yogurt!! LOVE!!format_quote

February 28th, 2021 person_outline Julie S.
star star star star star

format_quoteOh my gosh this tastes GOOD!format_quote

February 14th, 2021 person_outline Mary S.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk takes me back to my childhood on the farm, always fresh and delicious. Shelf life in the refrigerator is long too.format_quote

February 8th, 2021 person_outline Elle M.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk is consistently fantastic! I was tempted and ordered from another provider because it was cheaper... I will never stray again! It also make the creamiest most delicious yogurt!! Highly recommend format_quote

February 2nd, 2021 person_outline Heather W.
star star star star star

format_quoteI love this milk ! It lasts longer than the grocery store milk as well. It’s a weekly orderformat_quote

January 28th, 2021 person_outline Colette T.
star star star star star

format_quoteBEST tasting milk!!!!!format_quote

January 8th, 2021 person_outline Brandi T.
star star star star star

format_quoteLove this milk. I ordered it specifically for holiday gluten free baking. It really made a difference in texture of gf cookies. Highly recommend. Will order again and again! format_quote

December 28th, 2020 person_outline Renee W.
star star star star star

format_quoteThe only milk I can drink straight. Tastes just like the fresh milk I grew up with. Absolutely love it. So happy to have found this product. format_quote

December 23rd, 2020 person_outline Petra S.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis is the first whole milk I've ever drank that tastes rich and creamy and I don't care about the calories, it tastes that good! No coating left in your mouth and just shake and the bits of butter reintegrate back onto the milk. Fantastic! format_quote

December 22nd, 2020 person_outline Ella W.
star star star star star

format_quoteLove this milk for kefir and making cheese. The little ones love it too. Great milk. Reasonable price.format_quote

December 17th, 2020 person_outline Rose D.
star star star star star

format_quoteMakes great mozzarella!! format_quote

December 10th, 2020 person_outline Amber G.
star star star star star

format_quoteI don’t like milk much, rarely drink it.Bad memories of smelly milk cartons in the school dumpster while on recess. I wanted to try this and see if I could tell a difference. Well, I just bought it for the second time. I actually drank the entire 1/2 gallon by myself, which has never happened before. This is good milk!format_quote

December 8th, 2020 person_outline Jennifer S.
star star star star star

format_quoteBest Milk I have ever had, since I was a kid and the milk man delivered.format_quote

November 23rd, 2020 person_outline Charlya D.
star star star star star

format_quoteI'd forgotten how good milk actually tastes. Wonderful for cooking, baking and making yogurt. I will never go back to store-bought again. format_quote

November 22nd, 2020 person_outline Kathryn W.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk is so good! Much better than store bought. I make my own yogurt and I'm excited start using fresh, local milk for it!format_quote

November 19th, 2020 person_outline Michelle R.
star star star star star

format_quoteThe milk last a lot longer than store milk and it taste better.format_quote

November 16th, 2020 person_outline shannon j.
star star star star star

format_quoteLove this milk. Being able to get fresh milk delivered to my door every week is a blessing.format_quote

October 29th, 2020 person_outline Jessie B.
star star star star star

format_quoteI may never buy milk in the store again. format_quote

October 27th, 2020 person_outline Sydney R.
star star star star star

format_quoteI'm hooked. Great milk and tastes just like the milk I had when I was a kid from the local dairy. I've forgotten how much I missed fresh milk!format_quote

October 16th, 2020 person_outline Min L.
star star star star star

format_quoteI don't think I've ever tasted milk this good. Love it and will be ordering again.format_quote

October 13th, 2020 person_outline Laura N.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis is the best milk taste is delicious i love it ordered again and will every 2 week thank you farmers format_quote

October 12th, 2020 person_outline sladjana g.
star star star star star

format_quoteAbsolutely Delicious! 💯format_quote

October 11th, 2020 person_outline Cami C.
star star star star star

format_quoteI loved it. Ordering again.format_quote

October 5th, 2020 person_outline Laura B.
star star star star star

format_quoteJust got my first order, and made my home made yogurt and as I am typing this my home made farmer cheese is getting ready! For same product I had to pay wholefood 6 $ per jug knowing the bulk of he money went to amazon Now ; I had the same goods and I am supporting my local farmer. It is fantastic I am hooked format_quote

September 25th, 2020 person_outline Bronia .
star star star star star

format_quoteBack in the 80s we lived in Illinois and twice a week a dairy farm would have their vats filled with fresh milk and we would go there in the evening with gallon jugs and fill them up ourselves and leave money in the jar. We have missed the wonderful taste of this fresh milk until now. My hubby is drinking milk again and we have gone from a 2 gallon order weekly to 3 gallons (for 4 people). Keep up the great work and know that what you are doing is so appreciated in our household. Thank you, Thank you, Thank you!format_quote

September 19th, 2020 person_outline Tracy B.
star star star star star

format_quoteHow milk used to taste when I was growing up format_quote

September 13th, 2020 person_outline Melinda .
star star star star star

format_quoteHow milk should taste! Never going back to Kroger or Giant Eagle ever again for milk. The cream on top is so delicious too! format_quote

September 4th, 2020 person_outline Trevor S.
star star star star star

format_quoteI'm used to drinking fairlife milk so this took a bit of getting used to because it's a bit thinner in consistency even if you shake it. But the taste is unmatched. It's very rich and delicious. I use it to make lattes! So delicious. format_quote

September 3rd, 2020 person_outline Lauren T.
star star star star star

format_quoteHappy, Happy, Happy. Gotta love that coffee in the morning with this milk. Well, my morning shredded wheat with fresh fruit tastes pretty awesome, too. I'm spoiled. Two half gallons spoiled me.format_quote

September 1st, 2020 person_outline Sandra V.
star star star star star

format_quoteI used to buy Hartzler's Dairy milk because I prefer the unhomogenized, but this is just as good and I don't have to pay a bottle deposit. The fact that it's also easier to shake up since it's not as heavy plays a big part in that. Aside from that it tastes extremely fresh and serves wonderfully as my morning coffee creamer. Sidenote: My cats, who normally don't bother with milk, will go after this like it's catnip. Very highly recommended!format_quote

August 27th, 2020 person_outline Susan W.
star star star star star

format_quoteSeriously impressed, tried this, we loved it. I was in the store and saw a similar product (for almost twice the price) and it was nowhere near as good. This is miles above any other milk I've had.format_quote

August 20th, 2020 person_outline Frederic L.
star star star star star

format_quoteWhen I was young we use to have milk delivered to our house. I've often think of those memories. Now I am enjoying the same! The milk is fresh and creamy! We love it and that you deliver it to us. We will continue to buy it- Thank you!format_quote

August 7th, 2020 person_outline Stephanie C.
star star star star star

format_quoteOh wow. This milk is real nice. My 11 year old had a cup too and said “this tastes different. It’s different but really good.”format_quote

August 6th, 2020 person_outline Sarah B.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk is delicious. Its so fresh that it took a few days for the cream to separate from the milk. The cream is so thick and buttery, it's amazing. I have been buying non-homogenized milk for a while, but it's hard to find locally. I love that this is delivered right to my door. I will be purchasing regularly.format_quote

August 2nd, 2020 person_outline Samantha N.
star star star star star

format_quoteI only lasted one meal! My kids were so facinated by it being non homogenized. They loved the flavor.format_quote

July 29th, 2020 person_outline lena g.
star star star star star

format_quoteMy wife and I love how this milk tastes. Lucky if the g Half gallon makes it until the next deliveryformat_quote

July 28th, 2020 person_outline Douglas H.
star star star star star

format_quoteStore bought milk often sours before the half gallon is empty because I bought it as an ingredient for a recipe and don’t drink it. That will not happen with this milk. I find myself opening the refrigerator and grabbing this bottle to pour myself a glass “just because”.format_quote

July 25th, 2020 person_outline Donna J.
star star star star star

format_quoteThe best milk I have ever bought. What a nice clean flavor. I order more every week to make sure I never run out. Happy cows= Happy customersformat_quote

July 21st, 2020 person_outline Jeremy R.
star star star star star

format_quoteI love this milk! It is a bit of a splurge, but it is so worth it. The cows that make it must be very happy. format_quote

July 16th, 2020 person_outline Karen F.
star star star star star

format_quotePhenomenal milk and just can't get enough of it. The first time in years I have been able to drink milk. Love the milk!format_quote

June 22nd, 2020 person_outline Tricia P.
star star star star star

format_quoteShort story, my wife and I grew up in Des Moines, Iowa, there was a dairy (AE dairy)there that had been in business long before I was born(lets just say back in the 30s-40. And they had the best milk and cottage cheese and chocolate milk. Well we think that this milk compare to that dairy's products. They are absolutely hands down the best that we have found.format_quote

June 13th, 2020 person_outline Lew w.
star star star star star

format_quoteAmazing milk that tastes great! I tried this one out and found that real milk along with A2 milk is so much easier on my youngest's stomach since normally he gets constipated easily. Having the enzymes still in it has helped immensely! format_quote

June 7th, 2020 person_outline Ashley .
star star star star star

format_quoteMy boyfriend is hooked after one sip he doesn't wanna leave the jug alone. It tastes really good I feel its better than the milk we get at the grocery store.format_quote

June 5th, 2020 person_outline Morgan K.
star star star star star

format_quoteAbsolutely the best milk I have ever had. I have told my family out of state that when they come visit next they have to try this milk. format_quote

June 5th, 2020 person_outline Rosalie O.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk is so delicious! I had forgotten how wonderfully good whole milk could be.! Thank you for making it possible for us to experience such a wonderful product😁format_quote

May 31st, 2020 person_outline Carolmarie S.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis is so good! And I don't usually drink milk. format_quote

May 30th, 2020 person_outline Deborah R.
star star star star star

format_quoteWe had switched over to all almond or oat milk prior to trying the Indian Creak Creamery milk, because store milk was simply without much taste and vitality. Drinking milk is enjoyable again. Especially delicious warmed up as a “golden milk” nightcap, with turmeric, cinnamon and a touch of Ohio maple syrup. Thanks for the excellent product, Indian Creek! format_quote

May 29th, 2020 person_outline Kathryn F.
star star star star star

format_quoteO-M-G! This milk is the best and creamiest milk I’ve ever had! My 5 year old granddaughter absolutely loves it!! She makes us warm it up! Definitely my new go to milk. Honestly don’t plan on drinking any other. format_quote

May 28th, 2020 person_outline Erica B.
star star star star star

format_quoteEqual in taste to a good organic. Highly recommended! format_quote

May 23rd, 2020 person_outline Royal M.
star star star star star

format_quoteFirst time order. Milk was Sooo good. So creamy.format_quote

May 22nd, 2020 person_outline BETTY M.
star star star star star

format_quoteFavorite milk to buy!format_quote

May 21st, 2020 person_outline Laurel G.
star star star star star

format_quoteFresh and delicious. Love itformat_quote

May 17th, 2020 person_outline Teresa Y.
star star star star star

format_quoteWe are hooked on this milk! Love the freshness, flavor, and supporting local dairy.format_quote

May 15th, 2020 person_outline Andrew C.
star star star star star

format_quoteheavenly format_quote

May 7th, 2020 person_outline christina j.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk takes me back to my youth on the ranch - so fresh and just god tasting. Thanksformat_quote

May 7th, 2020 person_outline FLOY A.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis is the best milk i have ever had. format_quote

May 6th, 2020 person_outline Cheryl P.
star star star star star

format_quoteAbsolutely delicious.format_quote

May 2nd, 2020 person_outline Cassandra .
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk is awesome! I doubt that I’ll be able to go back to store milk again!format_quote

April 30th, 2020 person_outline Mychael O.
star star star star star

format_quoteOur family loves it!format_quote

April 29th, 2020 person_outline Tammie N.
star star star star star

format_quoteI'm not a huge milk drinker but this milk is amazing! The entire half gallon was gone the day we opened it.. oops! format_quote

April 23rd, 2020 person_outline Caitlin J.
star star star star star

format_quoteSome of the best milk I've ever tasted!! And I share it with friends!!format_quote

April 21st, 2020 person_outline Timothy S.
star star star star star

format_quoteMy family loves it!format_quote

April 18th, 2020 person_outline Kristin F.
star star star star star

format_quoteMy family LOVES this milk!! They drink about a jug a day, I'm constantly needing more!format_quote

April 16th, 2020 person_outline Holli W.
star star star star star

format_quoteOne word - DELICIOUS!! So much better than the store-bought milk. I will definitely be ordering again.format_quote

April 16th, 2020 person_outline Amanda .
star star star star star

format_quoteAmazing! My son, who loves milk, was dumbfounded. He asked me, “What have I been drinking my whole life? Whiteout?” LOL. So glad we found you!format_quote

April 16th, 2020 person_outline Kim C.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk is seriously MAGIC. Magical tasting at least. We thought it was the coffee, then we thought it was the way we brewed the coffee, but no, it’s the milk! This milk is the best milk I have ever had and it has likely ruined regular whole milk for us. Wasn’t expecting something like milk to be so much better. Thanks!format_quote

April 14th, 2020 person_outline Jennifer J.
star star star star star

format_quoteI am so happy I came across this. The milk is sooooooo delicious and creamy. Wasn’t a big milk drinker until now. format_quote

April 13th, 2020 person_outline Shirley G.
star star star star star

format_quoteVery natural, pleasant taste. There is often a thick layer of cream at the top, which was be shaken but also used in recipes calling for fat. I can certainly keep drinking that every week.format_quote

April 13th, 2020 person_outline Philippe G.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis is every bit as delicious as I remembered from my childhood, long long ago. I can't believe I drank 1/2 gallon in one week. I am not a milk drinker...well I wasn't … but I am now! format_quote

April 10th, 2020 person_outline Berna Deene S.
star star star star star

format_quoteDelicious milk! Even my super picky whole milk drinkers love this milk. It’s a weekly order for us now! format_quote

April 6th, 2020 person_outline Amanda B.
star star star star star

format_quoteAbsolutely delicious. I bought this milk because I wanted to try it in cheese making. I found it so tasty that I drank 1/3 of what I bought before starting on the cheese. The cheese is ripening and looks beautiful. I can't wait. format_quote

March 9th, 2020 person_outline Nancy M.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis is how milk is supposed to taste !!! I use local raw honey and this milk in our coffee daily and it is excellent!! No complaints. Will continue to order format_quote

March 8th, 2020 person_outline Nikki C.
star star star star star

format_quoteI grew up on a Pennsylvania dairy farm in the 80s milking over 100 head daily. This milk takes me back to then. I will continue to order it, and through Market Wagon I can not complain about anything. The quality of the milk is wonderful, creamy and yes, there is cream on top. Thank you for bringing this too us. I have it on auto ship weekely now. format_quote

March 3rd, 2020 person_outline Paul .
star star star star star

format_quoteCreamy, filling, smooth and delicious! There is a definite difference in quality between Indian Creek creamery milk and anything you can buy at the store. I only wish they could start packaging in reusable glass vs plastic. format_quote

February 28th, 2020 person_outline Heather A.
star star star star star

format_quoteFirst time in years enjoying fresh milk again. Slept like a baby with my small glass before bed. Can't wait for more! Great work all:)format_quote

February 21st, 2020 person_outline Jeff D.
star star star star star

format_quoteSo good. Very creamyformat_quote

February 18th, 2020 person_outline Stephanie Q.
star star star star star

format_quoteBest milk I've had, now that I saw the A2 I'll be buying that but both taste amazing!format_quote

February 3rd, 2020 person_outline Nicole L.
star star star star star

format_quoteBest milk I've ever had. Love the creamy taste Very delicious!! Our family loves this milk! I have a daughter who is lactose intolerant and this milk settles great with her and she loves it. format_quote

February 1st, 2020 person_outline Danielle v.
star star star star star

format_quoteTastes just like what I remember having as a kid at my grandma's. Absolutely delicious!! So glad I found you!!format_quote

January 28th, 2020 person_outline Shirley W.
star star star star star

format_quoteDelicious! My kids love it. Almost done with one half gallon in a day! Glad I bought two. format_quote

January 2nd, 2020 person_outline Mana H.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis is some of the best milk you will drink!!!! My son loves it!format_quote

December 13th, 2019 person_outline Jason M.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis is fantastic milk. The rich creaminess makes all the difference in my baked goods, especially milk bread. format_quote

November 22nd, 2019 person_outline Terrie H.
star star star star star

format_quoteWe are very happy with this milk. It's rich and so fresh that I only have to place an order every 2 weeks. The cream rises to the top just like it used to in the milk we used to get when I was young. It tastes like the old Young's Dairy milk used to when they were allowed to sell the milk straight from the cow but it's still pasteurized enough to make it completely safe. format_quote

November 22nd, 2019 person_outline Ruth F.
star star star star star

format_quoteBest milk ever! My kids love it and don’t even ask to add chocolate to it. format_quote

October 8th, 2019 person_outline Sarah H.
star star star star star

format_quoteThe best milk ever I am lactose intolerant but with this milk I can drink it just fineformat_quote

October 3rd, 2019 person_outline Hawa B.
star star star star star

format_quoteI haven't been able to drink milk in years. I read the reviews on your milk and decided to order some myself. I was so excited to receive it, first thing I did was make cornbread and poured milk over it. Absolutely amazing. format_quote

September 25th, 2019 person_outline Joy H.
star star star star star

format_quoteI love this milk. I let it get good and cold and then drink half the bottle!format_quote

August 3rd, 2019 person_outline timothy m.
star star star star star

format_quote format_quote

August 2nd, 2019 person_outline Jeremy L.
star star star star star

format_quoteDelicious! We use this for drinking, making cheese, yogurt, and hopefully will try making butter soon!format_quote

July 23rd, 2019 person_outline Nicole O.
star star star star star

format_quoteSo yummy! My kids loved this milk and drank half the jug within an hour of getting it home. Also did a blind taste test with my husband and he chose Indian creek over store bought easily. Said it tasted so fresh.format_quote

June 6th, 2019 person_outline Tiffani .
star star star star star

format_quoteLike milk tasted when we had our own cows growing up! This milk is amazing. You can taste the difference! format_quote

June 6th, 2019 person_outline Melissa B.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk is absolutely wonderful! It's like the fresh milk I had as a child in the early 1960's! It's very reasonably priced too.format_quote

April 25th, 2019 person_outline Judi L.
star star star star star

format_quoteFantastic product! Milk is rich and creamy and delicious! And to have it delivered to my door is just amazing!!! Thank you!!!format_quote

April 15th, 2019 person_outline Tonja M.
star star star star star

format_quoteIt has been years since I have drank milk, so I gave yours a try, and I love it! The taste is so excellent! Thank you for putting out a great product! format_quote

March 25th, 2019 person_outline Derrick A.
star star star star star

format_quoteGreat quality milk. My son who has issues with dairy is able to drink this milk with no problem. format_quote

March 16th, 2019 person_outline
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk is full bodied and a pleasure to drink!format_quote

March 4th, 2019 person_outline Gina Kay Landis
Click Here to learn how you can start shopping with friends, discussing products, and sharing your favorites.