5.0 from 58 reviews
Leave a Review

You've bought this product 0 times.

You've bought from this vendor 0 times.

Indian Creek Creamery

A2/A2 Whole Milk - Non-Homogenized

Dairy Products: Milk

Our A2/A2 milk comes from cows that have been tested to produce milk that only contains the A2/A2 beta-casein protein. Many with milk sensitivities can drink this milk with no issues. Our milk is bottled the same day it comes from the cow. Because it is non-homogenized, the cream rises to the top, so if you don't want to skim the cream off the top for your coffee or other purposes, please be sure to SHAKE WELL to distribute the cream through the milk to enjoy the rich, creamy taste of milk as nature intended!USA / Ohio / Logan County


You must login or register to ask questions in the product forum.
Q: Any updates when the A2 milk might be available again?

A: 'My husband has met with someone who may be willing to take our milk to NEO....hopefully we will hear soon!'

January 16th, 2022 person_outline Lisa G.
Q: When will your A2 a2 milk be available again in NE Ohio?

A: 'We are actively looking for a way to get our milk back to the NEO hub again. We will keep working on it!'

January 16th, 2022 person_outline Leah W.
Q: grass

A: 'Our cows always have access to pasture.'

January 6th, 2022 person_outline Zack R.
Q: I order your milk each week. It is even good beyond the date indicated. I LOVE YOUR MILK. The best ever. I am grateful that you are one market wagon. Thank You. I get cream if I do not shake well and it is so good.

A: 'Thank you so much for your kind remarks! We are so glad that you enjoy our milk:)'

January 3rd, 2022 person_outline Judy B.
Q: Can you suggest a way to get the cream off the top to use for my coffee since it's in the jug with narrow top?

A: 'The best and easiest way to get the cream from the jug is with a turkey baster:)'

December 26th, 2021 person_outline Julie S.
Q: Do you sell your milk in any stores? I’m willing to travel to get it!!

A: 'If you look on our Facebook page or our website, you will find a list of stores that carry our milk. '

November 22nd, 2021 person_outline Nancy L.
Q: I am disappointed that I can not get A2 milk this week from you. I only drink your milk. I love it. When will I be able to get it again? I'm totally out of it.

A: 'I am so sorry but I do not have a definite date as to when we will be able to get back up to the Northeast Ohio Market Wagon hub. Hopefully we can work things out very soon!'

November 9th, 2021 person_outline Kathy L.
Q: When will this be available again in northeast Ohio?? My order was canceled and I wasn't given a reason as to why it isn't available. It seems to be available in other areas so I was just wondering what happened. It is the only milk my daughter can drink:(

A: 'We are so sorry that it is taking us longer than we thought to find a solution to our logistic issues in order to get our milk to the NEO market. We are a small family farm and are doing our best to get back to NEO. We appreciate our customers and your patience!'

July 12th, 2021 person_outline Tiffani R.
Q: Why have you dropped the local market in NE Ohio? Disappointing.

A: 'We are a small family farm and are having issues logistically in getting our milk to the NEO Market Wagon hub on Thursday mornings. We are working hard to figure out a solution so that we can get our milk back there. We appreciate everyone's patience as we work on this.'

July 6th, 2021 person_outline James P.
Q: I love your milk. I LOVE YOUR MILK. The best we have ever had. Thank you. Judy Bozick 614-6024

A: 'Thank you so much! We love to hear from our customers:)'

June 20th, 2021 person_outline Judy B.
Q: I like your A2 non homogenized milk and ordered 8 half gallon bottles that got delivered to me on April 27th. All of them were marked with a use by date of May 10th. But on May 7th evening milk in on of the opened bottles was spoiled .So we tried a new unopened bottle on May 8th morning and found that the milk smelled diff and when boiled started to curdle. 2 bottles of unopened milk is now spoiled. I ordered 8 more bottles which are scheduled for delivery on May 11th . I refrigerated the milk in less than 30 minutes after delivery. What could have possibly caused this? Were the bottles marked with wrong dates? Thank you

A: 'The best by date is correct and we don't get this problem often, so makes me wonder if we should request more ice packs for your situation. There is normally 2 packed in with milk. Possibly could request this when you order, Thank you, Ray , Indian Creek Creamery'

May 26th, 2021 person_outline Kamala P.
Q: Is your milk from a Guernsey and/or Jersey herd? I grew up on a Guernsey farm and tend to prefer the richer milk - I know they are often the A2 producers...

A: 'We milk mostly Holsteins - one Jersey:) While you are correct that Guernseys and Jerseys are known for richer milk, over the years we have bred our cows with an emphasis on butterfat, protein, and the A2 beta casein. Thank you for taking the time to reach out to us and for trying our milk! We appreciate our customers :)'

May 25th, 2021 person_outline Rebecca W.
Q: No vitamin D added, correct?

A: 'No, we do not add anything or take anything out of our milk. '

May 18th, 2021 person_outline Elizabeth M.
Q: I love your milk. I did not like milk before, but I do now. You told me ho to freeze the milk. I put in the freezer than thawd in in the frige. It is GREAT. Taste wonderful with consistency good also. It has ice milk ice chips and reminds me of camp. That is how I used to like milk a very long time ago. Thank you cery much.

A: 'You are so welcome! Thank you so much for your kind remarks....we appreciate them:)'

January 31st, 2021 person_outline Judy B.
Q: I would get try out your milk but I don't see a 2% milk being offered.

A: 'No, we only offer whole milk and A2 milk at this time. We do not want to alter the milk in any way, and new dietary information suggests that naturally occurring fats are not as bad as people were previously led to believe. '

January 23rd, 2021 person_outline Patrick S.
Q: Is this milk organic?

A: 'No, our milk is not organic, but we do feed our cows non- GMO feed, we do not use rBST, and our cows love to spend their time out in the pasture:) Our cows all have names and unique personalities - which is what makes dairy farming fun:) '

January 8th, 2021 person_outline AshleyPaul .
Q: Do you make any Amish butter or goat milk? Thanks

A: 'No we do not . We only milk dairy cows.'

December 28th, 2020 person_outline Hala .
Q: do you sell whipping cream?

A: No, I'm sorry but we do not offer whipping cream at this time.

December 28th, 2020 person_outline Carissa B.
Q: I ordered to many half gal by mistake. I tried to cancel it and start over. I only want 2 half gal of whole milk.

A: All of the orders are handled by Market Wagon. We don't have access to change orders. Please try to reach Market Wagon directly to see if they cancelled your order. Please let me know if you need help with that and I will try to get ahold of someone for you. Thank you for your business!

December 22nd, 2020 person_outline SUZIE D.
Q: I have monthly subscription, when I tried to order today (9/8) I see shipping charges on my order and I didn't order. I missing this Thursday shipping. Please let me know what went wrong and what needs to be done to get it.

A: I am sorry to hear you are having trouble with that. This would be a question for Market Wagon, though. They distribute and do the billing for all the products they offer on their website. Vendors simply drop off our products and Market Wagon takes it from there. I hope you will reach out to them directly to straighten things out. Good Luck!

November 22nd, 2020 person_outline Narendiran .
Q: Do you have any milk for diabetics

A: We only sell whole milk. That said, our A2 milk may be an option, as some studies have shown it does not cause diabetes in test subjects. I am sorry I cannot be of more help!

November 21st, 2020 person_outline Angela C.
Q: What is the protein amount per serving?

A: I'm not sure if this will answer your question or not, but when we test our milk from our bulk tank, it tests at 3.17% protein. I hope that helps!

November 8th, 2020 person_outline Lily K.
Q: It’s not as creamy as before. What has changed? It was difficult to get the milk from the bottle as there used to be thick layer of heavy cream on top. Now it’s like water.

A: Are you referring to milk that you got today? If so, the milk was just bottled and the cream probably hasn’t had time to completely separate. If you leave it sit for a day or two, the cream will settle out more. The taste should be the same as your previous jug after it was shaken. I hope that helps!

November 3rd, 2020 person_outline Nivedita .
Q: what size is this gallon , 1/2 gallon or quart ?

A: It is 64 fl.oz. ( half-gallon)

November 3rd, 2020 person_outline Debbie E.
Q: The method for pasteurizing, it's not ultra pasteurized is it? I want to make yogurt with it.

A: No, we do not ultra pasteurize our milk. It works great for yogurt!

October 28th, 2020 person_outline Christina B.
Q: Do you offer a lactose free option?

A: No, we do not at this time. Thanks for asking!

October 20th, 2020 person_outline Dawn G.
Q: Are your cows rBGH/rBST treated ?

A: No they are not.

September 17th, 2020 person_outline Maria A.
Q: Are your cows 100% grass fed? If not, how do you supplement their diets?

A: They are not 100% grass fed. They do have pasture access when the weather is nice but on days that it is not fit to pasture we feed them a ration that our nutritionist puts together for the cows. The diet is mostly forages, that we harvest and dry or ferment to store for when the cows are in the barn. The diet also has a small amount of non-gmo ground corn, soybeans, and the minerals and vitamins the cows need.

September 17th, 2020 person_outline Joanna .
Q: I know this is non-homogenized, but is it also unpasteurized? And if not, do you offer unpasteurized whole milk?

A: Our milk is pasteurized using a high temperature/ short time pasteurizer, which quickly heats the milk for 15 seconds then cools it immediately. It is not legal in Ohio to sell raw milk, but in more than one blind taste test people find our milk tastes just like raw milk. We hope you will give it a try! Thank you for your question.

September 13th, 2020 person_outline Corbett S.
Q: Can this be used to make curds? Or cheese?

A: Yes- others have used our milk for that purpose.

August 11th, 2020 person_outline Kevin K.
Q: Do you ever plan to move these to a non-plastic container? Love the milk - but wish it was a different container!

A: We do not plan on switching to glass bottles. We did look into it, but the cost of bottles and the labor required to wash them is too much for us. My husband and I milk our 70 cows, bottle the milk, and sell/deliver the milk ourselves so we just cannot add any more to our workload at this time. I appreciate your question - thank you for giving our milk a try!

August 6th, 2020 person_outline TONYA S.
Q: Is this different that the Whole Milk sold by the same vendor?

A: Yes, this is different than the whole milk. The A2/A2 milk contains only A2 beta-casein, while the whole milk has both A1 and A2 beta-caseins. Many who have lactose sensitivities have found that the A2 milk is easier for them to digest, causing less bloating. Sometimes, though, the whole milk we provide is easier to digest because we do not homogenize our milk. Thank you for your question!

July 24th, 2020 person_outline Betsy .
Q: Can you make butter with your a2 milk?

A: Yes you can:) Thank you for your question!

July 10th, 2020 person_outline BRENDA H.
Q: If u have butter then let me know

A: No butter yet, but should be coming soon!

July 9th, 2020 person_outline Khara S.
Q: Do u have butter?

A: We are working on adding butter to our offerings as soon as we can.

June 30th, 2020 person_outline Khara S.
Q: How do I find out if there is a pick up spot near me? 45242

A: That is a question for someone from Market Wagon- we only deliver our milk to their hub.

June 11th, 2020 person_outline Mary B.
Q: Are there still enzymes left in milk using the HTST pasteurizer?

A: Yes, from our research enzymes are destroyed at 180 degrees. Which is why our milk is pasteurized below that temperature.

June 9th, 2020 person_outline Rebecca W.
Q: Is this a half gallon?

A: Yes it is:)

June 7th, 2020 person_outline Gina H.
Q: What is A2 beta casein protein?

A: Simply put, cows can produce two kinds of casein protein...A1 or A2. Genetics determine which version they produce. Research shows that the A2 protein is more easily digestible which is why A2 milk has become something that consumers are interested in trying. There are several books and research articles available on the subject if you are interested in a more detailed explanation.

June 3rd, 2020 person_outline Gina H.
Q: Is this pasteurized?

A: Yes it is. We use an HTST pasteurizer, which quickly heats and cools the milk - to sell milk in Ohio it must be pasteurized.

May 18th, 2020 person_outline Kerry L.
Q: Do you ever plan to sell containers of cream? I want to make clotted cream, and ultra-pasteurized does not work well.

A: Good morning! At this point in time, we do not have any plans to separate and package cream. Just to clarify, though, Ultra-pasteurized milk is heated to 275 degrees....we use an HTST pasteurizer which heats the milk to 161 degrees. I hope that helps! Thank you for your interest:)

May 17th, 2020 person_outline Dea H.
star star star star star

format_quoteIndian Creek has best milk I've had since fresh from grandpa's dairy decades ago. Son says the A2 reduces gas. He has a bit of milk intolerance. Beware though this will spoil you for other brands.format_quote

January 16th, 2022 person_outline Linda B.
star star star star star

format_quoteWe love this milk. We order it weekly.format_quote

January 16th, 2022 person_outline Eva .
star star star star star

format_quoteBest milk we have ever had, delicious!format_quote

January 6th, 2022 person_outline Audrey A.
star star star star star

format_quoteWonderful milk, we order weekly! format_quote

January 3rd, 2022 person_outline Aaron S.
star star star star star

format_quoteMy husband and family absolutely love milk from this farm. It’s hard to drink other brands of milk, we are so spoiled! I highly recommend! format_quote

December 26th, 2021 person_outline Carolyn L.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk is a reminder of the milk I drank as a child. It is like unlike any other milk in the present day. The present milk is very sweet. This milk is not sweet.format_quote

November 22nd, 2021 person_outline Donnalyn M.
star star star star star

format_quoteWonderful milk, we order it every week. format_quote

November 9th, 2021 person_outline Kelli S.
star star star star star

format_quoteDelicious milk... my husband, who has Stage IV colon cancer and has digestive issues from the chemo and the cancer itself, LOVES this. It is wonderful, no stomach upset or vomiting, our favorite milk of all time. And that's saying something because he loves his buttermilk... says this is even better than that! format_quote

July 12th, 2021 person_outline Christine B.
star star star star star

format_quoteDelicious, our kids can’t stop drinking it! Our daughter who’s had problems with milk can drink this with no issues. Thank you!!!format_quote

July 6th, 2021 person_outline Sarah S. View Reply
star star star star star

format_quoteLove this milk, doesn't cause any digestive problems and tastes great. Love the cream on the top, use it on my oatmeal!! format_quote

June 20th, 2021 person_outline Florence M.
star star star star star

format_quoteSooo good!format_quote

May 26th, 2021 person_outline Pilar S.
star star star star star

format_quoteLove this milk! format_quote

May 25th, 2021 person_outline lynne t.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk is so much better than what you buy in the store. I like how cream settles on top. Taste very good. format_quote

May 18th, 2021 person_outline David B.
star star star star star

format_quoteVery happy with this milk.format_quote

January 31st, 2021 person_outline Dawn L.
star star star star star

format_quoteGreat taste and consistency. Love that it is A2 and fresh from local source. format_quote

January 23rd, 2021 person_outline Christian D.
star star star star star

format_quoteThe a2 milk is amazing. And allows the lactose intolerant in our family to drink milk. I highly recommend their milk.format_quote

January 8th, 2021 person_outline Jason T.
star star star star star

format_quoteStore bought milk no more! Can’t even compare to how fresh and creamy this A2 milk is! So good too! My family made these super rich milk shakes with the milk that was out of this world fantastic with no ill effects or nasty aftertaste! Thanks Indian Creek Creamery!!format_quote

December 28th, 2020 person_outline Angela W.
star star star star star

format_quoteTook a chance in this A2/A2 milk after loving their whole milk and cream. Husband cannot tolerate milk and really missed cereal! This milk however, allows him to eat cereal freely! Three days in a row. ZERO gastro issues!! So happy with this milk and grateful that it tastes so good! Highly recommend. Just ordered our 2nd half gallon. No issues with the cream on top, just shake thoroughly as advised. format_quote

December 28th, 2020 person_outline Renee W.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk down not upset my stomach. It tastes rich without leaving a coating in my mouth. It also lasts till the expiration date. Very highly recommend! format_quote

December 22nd, 2020 person_outline Ella W.
star star star star star

format_quoteAwesome, kick-rear end, wholesome milk. As good as it gets.format_quote

November 22nd, 2020 person_outline TD G.
star star star star star

format_quoteI LOVE this milk. NO AFTER TASTE!!! S o smooth and creamy format_quote

November 21st, 2020 person_outline BARBARA C.
star star star star star

format_quoteVery creamy. Great REAL milk taste! No funky aftertaste. format_quote

November 8th, 2020 person_outline will h.
star star star star star

format_quoteWe have lactose issues, and tried this milk to see if it would work for us. It does! AND it is delicious!format_quote

November 3rd, 2020 person_outline Lily K.
star star star star star

format_quoteI have lactose/dairy issues and I can drink this! It's amazing. I can have milk in my coffee again! Thank you! format_quote

November 3rd, 2020 person_outline Erica S.
star star star star star

format_quoteThe best tasting milk, and the closet to raw that you can get! Love it.format_quote

October 28th, 2020 person_outline Dianah B.
star star star star star

format_quoteIt was good. No problems even with the lactose sensitive people in the house.format_quote

October 20th, 2020 person_outline Michelle L.
star star star star star

format_quoteIt is so good! I was blown away how long it stays good for and that it causes no issues! format_quote

September 17th, 2020 person_outline Sierra L.
star star star star star

format_quoteDelicious. Well worth the price.format_quote

September 17th, 2020 person_outline Ann S.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis is hands-down THE best milk I’ve ever had. As much as I love milk, it doesn’t love me, so I’ve pretty much had to give it up...or suffer the consequences! This is now my go-to milk and I can drink as much as I want without any problems. And the taste...WOW! format_quote

September 13th, 2020 person_outline Lisa G.
star star star star star

format_quoteMy daughter is lactose intolerant and she loves this milk. It causes no issues for her. My whole family loves it and it is amazing in quality! I will never buy any other milk again. Thank you!!!!format_quote

August 11th, 2020 person_outline Tiffani R.
star star star star star

format_quoteSo creamy and delicious. I have started drinking more milk now.format_quote

August 6th, 2020 person_outline Shirley G.
star star star star star

format_quoteMy family loved this creamy, sweet milk! My partner says it tastes like the fresh milk on his aunt’s dairy farm from when he was a boy.format_quote

July 24th, 2020 person_outline J T.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk is SO good and it really does help with dairy sensitivities. Regular milk Puts me on at least a 7/10 on the discomfort scale in the morning (10 being the most uncomfortable), but now I’m wayyyy down on the discomfort scale. All the way down to 1s and 2s. Milk mustaches can be had with comfort now!format_quote

July 10th, 2020 person_outline Jennifer J.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis is the best A2 milk I've found. I forgot what fresh tasted like until I found this!format_quote

July 9th, 2020 person_outline Mary W.
star star star star star

format_quoteAs close to raw milk as we have found. Our family is so happy to have milk we can enjoy and not have tummy issues.format_quote

June 30th, 2020 person_outline Tabitha H.
star star star star star

format_quoteGreat milk!format_quote

June 11th, 2020 person_outline Andrew C.
star star star star star

format_quoteJust received it & tastes great - I’m super thankful delivery is available. This is creamier.format_quote

June 9th, 2020 person_outline Rebecca H.
star star star star star

format_quoteI am in love with this milk! I normally am not a fan of whole milk, but I didn't realize that was because fresh tastes so much different than storebought; it's creamy with a sweet aftertaste. I definitely plan on ordering this weekly for my kiddos as well as getting a large jar to collect the cream for my own butter!format_quote

June 7th, 2020 person_outline Ashley .
star star star star star

format_quoteWe love this milk!format_quote

June 3rd, 2020 person_outline Jessica Y.
star star star star star

format_quoteGreat taste. Our four year old was beyond excited when it arrived!format_quote

May 18th, 2020 person_outline Gregory R.
star star star star star

format_quoteMy family won't drink any other milk now!format_quote

May 17th, 2020 person_outline Amanda B.
star star star star star

format_quoteLove this milk!!!format_quote

May 13th, 2020 person_outline Pat M.
star star star star star

format_quoteI haven’t drank a glass of cow’s milk in almost a decade, but this is so delicious and easy on my stomach. Will definitely purchase again!! Thank you!format_quote

May 2nd, 2020 person_outline Christine J.
star star star star star


May 2nd, 2020 person_outline Cassandra .
star star star star star


April 26th, 2020 person_outline Rickey M.
star star star star star

format_quoteLove this milk, so creamy and delicious, doesn’t upset my husband’s stomach. Never plan to go back to store bought milk again!format_quote

April 24th, 2020 person_outline Elyse S.
star star star star star

format_quoteGreat milk, especially if you are lactose intolerant!! I get two half gallons a week for a friend whose son is lactose intolerant.format_quote

April 21st, 2020 person_outline Timothy S.
star star star star star

format_quoteReal milk! As a kid, I loved being the first one up in the morning and spooning the cream off the top! As I have gotten older, found that my belly doesn't seem to tolerate milk so much. Very happy to have found and tried Indian Creek Creamery thru the Market Wagon! format_quote

April 19th, 2020 person_outline Rebecca C.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis is the best milk we have ever had. We will continue to purchase going forward. You can really tell how fresh it is and the difference between this milk and store bought.format_quote

April 17th, 2020 person_outline Carlee H.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk is hands down the best milk I’ve ever tasted! I have zero belly issues and am subscribing to weekly orders! format_quote

March 24th, 2020 person_outline Kelly B.
star star star star star

format_quoteBest milk I've ever tasted in my life. I can feel good about giving this to my kids knowing they are getting a premium product. Used one to make yogurt too which was also excellentformat_quote

February 3rd, 2020 person_outline Nicole L.
star star star star star

format_quoteLove it. format_quote

February 1st, 2020 person_outline Teresa J.
star star star star star

format_quoteVery good product. We buy for our growing toddler. Thank you! I'm selling everyone I know on it! I will say that I agree with the other reviewer that I thought it might be creamier though doesnt bother us that it's not. :)format_quote

January 9th, 2020 person_outline Rachel P.
star star star star star

format_quoteDelicious! The way milk is supposed to be.format_quote

January 8th, 2020 person_outline Kelly M.
star star star star star

format_quoteAmazing Milk, very nice taste, glad to find the real milk after so long time.format_quote

January 7th, 2020 person_outline Maria A.
star star star star star

format_quoteGave this milk a try because of lactose issues, and we do have less issues when using this milk. Really love the taste and consistency. So glad I found this!format_quote

October 28th, 2019 person_outline Linda .
star star star star star_outline

format_quoteVery nice milk. Didn't bother my stomach at all. Thought it might be a little creamier from what I've come to expect from other non-homogenized local milk, but was definitely worth getting delivered.format_quote

August 21st, 2019 person_outline Greg G.
star star star star star

format_quoteThis milk tastes so good! So refreshing! I can drink milk again!format_quote

July 13th, 2019 person_outline Sarah T.
Click Here to learn how you can start shopping with friends, discussing products, and sharing your favorites.